Mi Casa Mexican Restaurant Information

Tucked into the heart of Hartville at 903 W Maple St, Mi Casa Mexican Restaurant offers a warm, welcoming spot for anyone craving authentic Mexican flavors without leaving town. Walking in, you’re immediately greeted by the vibrant decor-brightly painted walls, handcrafted accents, and cheerful murals that give the space a lively, festive energy. The menu is a delightful mix of traditional favorites and creative twists, from perfectly spiced enchiladas and sizzling fajitas to crispy tacos filled with fresh, flavorful ingredients. One of the standout dishes is the chile relleno, boasting a rich, cheesy filling wrapped in a delicately fried pepper, paired effortlessly with fluffy Mexican rice and refried beans that taste like they came straight from a family kitchen. The service feels genuinely friendly and attentive, with staff ready to offer recommendations or craft drinks like house margaritas that balance sweetness and tang beautifully. Portions here are generous enough to share-or to take home for later, which many diners appreciate given the restaurant’s popularity during busy evenings and weekend lunch rushes. Reviews often highlight the consistency of flavor and the welcoming, casual atmosphere that makes Mi Casa a go-to spot for both a quick bite and a leisurely meal with friends or family. Whether you’re stopping by for a taco Tuesday treat or a full dinner experience, the combination of rich, authentic Mexican cuisine, inviting interior, and personable service ensures a dining experience that feels both satisfying and memorable, right in the heart of Hartville.

Most Popular Dishes

Burro Borracho $20.75

One big burrito stuffed with grilled steak or chicken with vegetables (onions, peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes). Accompanied with a portion of cheese nachos topped with pico de gallo. Side of rice and beans

Hartville Special $23.50

Thinly cut tender grilled steak with grilled onions(also available with grilled chicken breast), a chicken chimichurro topped with chile con queso and pico de gallo, served with rice, beans, fresh avocado slices and salad topped with sour cream.

Chicken Fiesta $23.50

A tender breaded chicken Milanesa and a chicken chimichanga topped with warm red salsa and sour cream. Served with rice, beans salad, and fresh avocado slices.

Double-Stacked Club Quesadillas $25.95

Two stacked quesadillas, covered in cheese, and served with a rice and a salad

Ibarra Special $33.00

Grilled steak and marinated chicken breast cooked “a las brasas” with grilled green onions and jalapeños, served with black beans, rice, and guacamole salad.

Special Fajita #1 $25.95

3 cheese chicken- smothered with melted pepper jack cheese, cheddar cheese, and creamy queso sauce

Special Fajita #2 $25.95

Hawaiian Chicken- topped with pico de gallo, sautéed peppers, and a splash of our tequila-citrus marinade

Mi Casa Special $23.50

A delicious sampler! Carnitas, one flauta and one enchilada with your choice of beef or chicken, a cheese quesadilla, rice, beans, and a guacamole salad.

Full Menu

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

The Mexican Birria pizza was excellent. A great version of Birria with wonderful flavor. Juicy and tender with a well balanced Consume.

I have seen unfortunate reviews about mi casa and today I am here to say that this is a total lie, I have visited mi casa for years and years and I only have good comments to offer, I have always been received along with my companions with a family and homely atmosphere, the food feels like homemade and they receive you like family. From the fresh and hot chips, the delicious sauce, the inevitable cheese dip, and every delicious dish (the best fajitas in the USA). I strongly recommend the restaurant mi casa for both lunch and dinner and it makes me disrespectful to falsely discredit the image of a place for a few dollars, what a pity that there are people like that. I invite you to visit the restaurant and try the wonderful food they offer here.

Listen. I’ve been going to mi casa since 2012. Here’s a few thoughts over the years. What they do well: they always remember I can’t have cheese or sourcream. The food is great. What is sometimes not done well: sometimes the service is really random. Like one day they will fill drinks and chips and another time crickets. I’ve also ordered catering from them. That was a little weird. I had a different person help me through every step of that process and there was definitely some lack of communication between all the workers. All in all it’s a good place.

Att first glance, this seems like your typical small mexican restaurant, but the servers pride in the food made it a standout. My hubby had his typical enchilada taco combo dinner, I ventured into the unknown with a Hawaiian bowl. So glad I did! The occasional surprise of grilled pineapple and fresh cilantro made this bowl special. The portion was plentiful, I couldn't come close to eating it all. The chips were fresh, warm and salty. Perfect! If you need a break from typical Amish fare, give this a try!!

Stopped in for some flan with a buddy of mine. That's all we got. That's all we wanted. It was good. Not great, but good. Wish it were a bit creamier. It was really heavy and thick, but had great flavor. Would like to go back and try out their lunch/dinner menu sometime.

Queso and salsa were both excellent. Salsa had super fresh ingredients and the queso was thick and spicy, not thin and bland like so many other places. Place was very busy on a Saturday at 12:30 so they forgot my rice and beans so the 4 stars on service but 5 stars everywhere else! I definitely recommend this restaurant!

Very friendly staff. Food comes fast and is delicious. I would highly recommend giving them a try. All the enchilada dishes are fabulous.

I eat here several times a month, and it’s consistently great. The prices, especially at lunch, are fantastic. The service is always spot on, and all the food is great. This is a great local place worth supporting.

Mi Casa Mexican Restaurant